Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparison of mean percent rodent control success, rodent damage and yield loss in wheat crop fields of three locations treated with different rodenticide baits

From: Efficacy of combined formulation of bromadiolone and cholecalciferol in reducing rodent population and damage in agricultural crop fields

Location

Treatments

Control success (%)

Cut tillers (%)

Yield loss (kg/ha)

Yield loss saved (kg/ha)

w.r.t. reference field

w.r.t. same field

Nurpur Bet

Distt Ludhiana

(n = 3 each)

T1

79.15 ± 1.67B

79.32 ± 1.66AB

3.25 ± 1.01B

129.17 ± 44.32B

139.42 ± 55.24A

 

T2

71.16 ± 4.24A

71.38 ± 4.20A

3.45 ± 1.07B

124.78 ± 33.25B

143.80 ± 86.57A

 

T3

77.09 ± 2.98B

77.28 ± 2.96A

2.93 ± 0.27AB

103.20 ± 18.23B

167.98 ± 60.24A

 

T4

90.42 ± 0.29C

90.50 ± 0.29B

1.04 ± 0.43A

38.45 ± 17.90A

230.14 ± 64.14B

 

Reference

6.69 ± 1.87C

268.59 ± 53.86C

Jandwala Bhime Shah

Distt Fazilka

(n = 3 each)

T1

60.16 ± 0.35A

63.33 ± 0.21A

2.97 ± 0.63B

111.56 ± 28.42B

132.16 ± 34.12A

 

T2

69.42 ± 1.16B

71.72 ± 1.09B

2.58 ± 0.35B

108.26 ± 21.44B

135.91 ± 30.04A

 

T3

75.72 ± 2.77B

77.52 ± 2.57B

2.84 ± 0.15B

100.60 ± 9.78B

143.58 ± 30.18A

 

T4

88.60 ± 0.60C

89.28 ± 0.63C

1.28 ± 0.43A

51.13 ± 13.39A

191.35 ± 35.29B

 

Reference

6.52 ± 0.89C

244.17 ± 24.59C

Ghasitpur

Distt Hoshiarpur

(n = 3 each)

T1

62.45 ± 3.79A

64.59 ± 3.60A

2.74 ± 0.31B

92.74 ± 16.10B

149.74 ± 31.80A

 

T2

66.52 ± 1.25AB

68.42 ± 1.18AB

1.82 ± 0.80AB

70.15 ± 31.60B

172.33 ± 30.03B

 

T3

70.74 ± 6.89AB

72.40 ± 6.50AB

2.99 ± 0.51B

103.70 ± 26.85B

138.79 ± 22.35A

 

T4

85.92 ± 3.77C

86.72 ± 3.56B

1.24 ± 0.64A

50.42 ± 26.77A

192.06 ± 35.39B

 

Reference

7.52 ± 0.51C

242.48 ± 24.69C

Mean

(n = 9 each)

T1

67.30 ± 3.25A

68.37 ± 3.00A

3.00 ± 0.36B

110.49 ± 9.96B

140.58 ± 21.02A

 

T2

69.08 ± 1.50A

69.88 ± 1.55A

2.62 ± 0.46B

101.06 ± 16.19

150.68 ± 29.30A

 

T3

74.65 ± 2.54A

75.18 ± 2.54A

2.92 ± 0.17B

102.50 ± 0.96B

149.25 ± 23.42A

 

T4

88.34 ± 1.30B

88.57 ± 1.30B

1.18 ± 0.24A

46.67 ± 4.12A

205.08 ± 23.89B

 

Reference

6.82 ± 0.47C

251.75 ± 8.44C

  1. Values are Mean ± SE, n = number of fields in each block, w.r.t. = with respect to, ZnP = Zinc phosphide, Br = Bromadiolone, Ch = Cholecalciferol, T1 = ZnP (2%), T2 = Br (0.005%), T3 = Br (0.0025%) + Ch (0.02%) and T4 = Br (0.0025%) + Ch (0.04%). Values with different superscripts (A–C) in a column differ significantly at P ≤ 0.05